UFC 111 Analysis: Shane Carwin vs Frank Mir
The stage is set this Saturday from the Prudential Center in Newark, New Jersey for the co-main event at UFC 111: St. Pierre VS Hardy as Shane Carwin battles Frank Mir for the UFC interim heavyweight title. More importantly, on the line is a shot at Brock Lesnar and you have to know that is the real prize for the winner. Sports betting fans need all the analysis they can get on this match-up as Mir and Carwin are pretty evenly matched.
Both men are just itching to get their shot at the former WWE star who has been away from the octagon for what seems like an eternity due to medical reasons. Carwin was slated to challenge Lesnar for his belt at UFC 106 in November, and then again at UFC 108, but the champ pulled out due to a severe case of diverticulitis, leaving Carwin in limbo for almost a year.
Most MMA fans know the history between Frank Mir and Brock Lesnar, but if you’re new to this sport, I’ll give you a little history lesson. These two heavyweights met at UFC 81 and early it was Lesnar dominating the action before Mir, the experienced jiu-jitsu fighter, caught Lesnar’s leg and submitted him via knee-bar. These two met again at UFC 100 and it was an utter destruction of Frank Mir.
But it wasn’t so much the loss that people were talking about after, but how Lesnar humiliated him and wiped it in everyone’s face afterwards. Since the loss, Mir has been a man possessed and is on a crusade to get redemption for what Lesnar did to him.
He has fully dedicated himself to the gym and has packed-on some 20 pounds of muscle to try and match Lesnar’s size. Fans got to see his new frame on display in a fight with Cheick Kongo, as he choked out the French fighter with ease at UFC 107.
Carwin is a man that has always been dedicated to the gym, and is quite the specimen himself. “The Engineer” comes into this fight with a perfect 11-0 record, with all his wins coming via knockout. Fans got to see just how powerful this guy is in his last outing at UFC 96, where Carwin put Gabriel Gonzaga to sleep in the 1st Round after connecting with a short-right hook. When I say short right hook, I mean a punch that most people would toss at their buddy’s shoulder but he has so much power that it knocked Gonzaga out cold.
The problem with Carwin is that he is unpolished and was losing that fight to Gonzaga badly before connecting with the one big shot. Having that power is nice, but you’re not always going to get lucky and Frank Mir isn’t a guy you want to expect to get lucky against.
Mir’s only blemish lately was that loss to Lesnar at UFC 100 last July, and has won four of his last five fights. With that rubber match on the line, I just don’t see how Mir can lose this. At -155, I’ll take Frank Mir and sit and wait for what is going to be the most legendary fight in the UFC history, Mir vs. Lesnar III.
Featured Upcoming Bouts (Outside of UFC)
| Thursday, December 31st 2026: Rizin FF Super Rizin 6: Shiwasu no Owarinagoya Gekokujo Matsuri | |||
|
| |||
| Last Fight Date: 9/10/2026 [Rizin Fighting Federation] Last Opponent: [#17 W105] Rena Kubota Last 5: W W W W W | Last Fight Date: 7/18/2026 [Rizin Fighting Federation] Last Opponent: [#12 W105] Ye Ji Lee Last 5: L W L W W | ||
| Sunday, December 13th 2026: Deep - 135 Impact | |||
|
| |||
| Last Fight Date: 5/04/2026 [DEEP] Last Opponent: [#6 SW] Sora Sugiyama Last 5: W W W W W | Last Fight Date: 9/13/2026 [DEEP] Last Opponent: [#24 SW] Daichi Kitakata Last 5: L L W L W | ||
| Sunday, December 13th 2026: Deep Tokyo Impact 2026 6th Round | |||
|
| |||
| Last Fight Date: 9/20/2026 [DEEP] Last Opponent: [NR] Musashi Musashi Last 5: W W W L W | Last Fight Date: 9/06/2026 [DEEP] Last Opponent: [#43 SW] Toshiya Takashima Last 5: W W W W W | ||

Featured Fighters
| [#5 HW] | Josh Hokit |   | [#1 HW] | Ciryl Gane |
| [#6 W135] | Amanda Nunes |   | [#53 MW] | Yousri Belgaroui |
| [#14 WW] | Uros Medic |   | [#82 FLW] | Bilal Hasan |
| [#32 LW] | Chris Duncan |   | [#1 WW] | Islam Makhachev |
| [#85 LW] | Jim Miller |   | [#1 W135] | Kayla Harrison |
UFC 111: How they stack up
UFC Welterweight Championship
[#1] Georges St. Pierre vs. [#6] Dan Hardy
UFC Interim Heavyweight Championship
[#5] Frank Mir vs. [#10] Shane Carwin
Lightweight
[#29] Kurt Pellegrino vs. [#43] Fabricio Camoes
Welterweight
[#2] Jon Fitch vs. [#28] Ben Saunders
Lightweight
[#14] Jim Miller vs. [#44] Mark Bocek
Welterweight
[#25 LW] Nate Diaz vs. [#88] Rory Markham
Welterweight
[#21 MW] Ricardo Almeida vs. [#52] Matt Brown
Light Heavyweight
[#44] Rodney Wallace vs. [#78] Jared Hamman
Middleweight
[#24] Rousimar Palhares vs. [#28] Tomasz Drwal
Welterweight
[#111] Greg Soto vs. [#188] Matt Riddle
February Archive published
Fightmatrix.com Mixed Martial Arts Rankings Archive has been updated with the rankings as of February 7, 2010.
This will likely be the final release of the ranking archives in the current format, as we are working on improving & expanding our historical rankings section.
UFC on Versus Review
UFC’s first event televised on the Versus network took place in Broomfield, Colorado – the home state of the first UFC event held back in 1993. Zuffa – UFC’s parent company – has been frequently using the Versus network to broadcast WEC events. For a period of time, a dispute between DirecTV and Comcast (the owners of Versus) kept the network off the screens of DirecTV subscribers. The dispute was resolved just in time for this event, allowing the first UFC on Versus to be broadcast to a wider audience.
Besides the network change, the other notable theme of this event was a reunion of the previous class of UFC’s heavyweights: Gabriel Gonzaga, Cheik Kongo, and the presently light-heavyweight Brandon Vera. All three fighters began their UFC careers within a year of each other, and all have received a varying degree of hype early in their careers, but consistently underachieved. All three had a pivotal matchup lined up for them on this card.
Alessio Sakara vs. James Irvin (185 lbs)
Round 1: Sakara is the aggressor early on, interchanging punch combinations with leg kicks. Irvin is tentative, defending and firing off an occasional leg kick. Sakara trips and falls while throwing a leg kick but gets up before Irvin has a chance to capitalize. Sakara lands a left hook and Irvin collapses, clutching his eye. Referee Josh Rosenthal pulls Sakara off before any more damage is done. Irvin complains about an eye poke but replay shows it was a clean punch that landed to the eye. After some hesitation, Rosenthal declares the bout a TKO victory for Sakara – the right call.
Aftermath: Alessio Sakara earns three consecutive wins for the first time in his UFC career. He should next take on the winner of the upcoming bout between Patrick Cote and Alan Belcher, or Vitor Belfort if he returns to action soon.
James Irvin looked completely flat in his first fight after a long layoff. Whether the cause was ring rust, a difficult cut for his first fight at 185 lbs, being gun-shy after his destruction at the hands of Anderson Silva, or a combination of all these factors, Irvin’s UFC career may be in jeopardy. Post-fight, the UFC President Dana White mentioned that if Irvin gets another chance, it will not be in the middleweight division.
Fight Grade: 2/5
January Archive Published
Fightmatrix.com Mixed Martial Arts Rankings Archive has been updated with the rankings as of January 3, 2010.
A mid-week update…
We’re still testing our new changes, so an intermediate update was just posted for 3/15/2010.
MMA Rankings Updated: 3/12/2009
Notable Info
- We decided to make a release this week as we’re debuting some changes. This change (so far) is undetectable on the surface, but we’re actually starting to move parts of our database online, so the ranking pages you see now are dynamically constructed. This will open up a ton of possibilities for us to post more data onto our web site
Fighter Search Feature added!
Our readers have been asking for this for a long time – and as we expanded to ranking 250 fighters in most divisions, it has become a necessity. Introducing the fighter search feature – now you can search our current ranking database for every fighter in the published lists, instead of having to look through countless pages to find a certain fighter.
Have you ever wondered how many Millers are ranked by Fight Matrix? Apparently 8 at the moment:
http://www.fightmatrix.com/fighter-search/?fName=Miller
Of course, Silvas have them beat:
http://www.fightmatrix.com/fighter-search/?fName=Silva
This means we are one step closer to making our entire ranking database searchable. In the coming weeks, we will be working on some additional improvements – soon we will have the ability to search for historical rankings, and eventually to track a fighter’s progress in rankings over time. As we are busy working on the new features, there will be no ranking release this weekend. The next release will be published after the ‘UFC on Versus’ event.
