De La Hoya plans to call it a career after a December bout, one where an opponent has not yet been finalized.  However, as it stands now, all signs point to a Welterweight showdown with boxing’s best pound-for-pound fighter, Manny Pacquiao.  At first glance, you’d think that the boxing world would take kindly to one of the generation’s best still near his prime facing the top fighter in the sport.  After all, it did when De La Hoya fought Mayweather just over a year ago.

However, a tremendous amount of boxing fans are taking offense to this potential match-up, one that has an outside shot to break all boxing pay-per-view records.

Why?  Most fans argue that Pacquiao is too small for the “Golden Boy”, but I beg to differ.  Yes, De La Hoya will have a distinct size advantage, but its nothing that we haven’t seen before.

The Main Argument Against the Fight

Manny Pacquiao started as a Flyweight.  This match-up is at Welterweight, which is 35 pounds above the Flyweight limit of 112.  Despite the fact that Pacquiao has tremendous skill and youth on his side, De La Hoya is no slouch and is simply too big for Pacquiao.

My Opinion

If you want to get technical, Manny Pacquiao weighed in at just 106 pounds for his first fight, which is just 1 pound above Minimumweight, the absolute lowest division in men’s boxing.

However, one needs to read between the lines and investigate this further before jumping to conclusions.

  1. Pacquiao is from a (once) very poor family, in a third world country.
  2. His debut took place only 5 weeks after his 16th birthday.

My point?  Before Pacquiao found fame and fortune, it is very likely that he was not getting suitable nutrition and was not done growing until the middle portion of his career.  Therefore, you can’t call him a “natural” Flyweight.  That argument is bunk and annoying.

Furthermore, have you seen Manny Pacquiao at a recent weigh-in?  His subcutaneous fat levels are minimal.  Not to mention, that he gained 12.5 pounds after his first weigh-in at Lightweight earlier this year.  HBO weighed him on fight night at 147 pounds.  In case you didn’t know, that is just 1 pound less than what Floyd Mayweather Jr. himself stated that he weighed on fight night versus De La Hoya.

With the need to trim down to only 147 rather than 135, it is very likely that Pacquiao could enter the De La Hoya fight at approximately 150 pounds.  De La Hoya will hold a slight weight advantage over him, but most experienced boxing fans expect this to only be in the area of 6-8 pounds, which is not a ridiculous difference.

I will admit, if you trust listed measurements, De La Hoya has 6 inches of reach and 4 inches of height on Pacquiao.  However, I highly doubt Pacquiao’s listed height and expect that difference to be closer to 5 inches.  Nevertheless, combat sports have weight divisions, not height or reach, so this fact is null and void, at least in my opinion.

These are the facts.

  1. Pacquiao has now grown into a legitimate Lightweight, and will probably end up campaigning at Light Welterweight (140) as he seems to be increasing his musculature like a madman.
  2. De La Hoya hasn’t made 147 since 2001.  He had to strip naked to make 150 in May 2008, so making weight will take its toll on him.
  3. Truly great boxers can nullify a disadvantage in weight using quickness and timing.  Two of Pacquiao’s best assets.
  4. These are two of the best boxers in last 15 years.  People need to shut up and appreciate the fact that they will share a ring together.

Contrary to common belief, this WILL be a competitive bout and one I will definitely watch.




Posted on August 7, 2008 by jcs

Boxing | Comments (3)




share this page

    3 Comments

    • Chris says:

      Farang

      Your miles wrong. Oscar generally only weighs 162-163 in the ring as a Light-Middleweight. How on earth would he hit 170, after weighing in at 147, 18 hours before.

      Pacquaio was in the ring weighing 147 as a ligtweight. The Welter limit. He will easily be 150 or even above at Welter.

      As for being “brave” Farang. Oscar has already fought pretty much the biggest middleweight in the last 30 years. He struggled with the weight against a tiny Sturm, and Hopkins was huge compared to Felix.

      Oscar vs. Hopkins was a huge mismatch. As in, Hopkins has already bullied Kelly around physically at light-heavy!?

      Beggers belief that you can call Oscar afraid to face Kelly, when he’s already faced the guy who just schooled him.

      And I should add, Oscar was ahead on a score card in that bout, before he got stopped. He put on a great performance

    • jcs says:

      Oscar will not enter at 170 or anywhere close. Absolutely no way. He is not a chronic drainer. The guy stays in shape and will have to be in great shape to make 147.

      BTW, if Oscar fought Pavlik, he himself would be 4 inches shorter…

    • farang says:

      You fail to state Oscar would come in to the fight @ 170 or so after making weigh-in, and Pacquiao would be lucky to hit 147.

      I think a much better opponent for brave Sir Oscar of the Hoya’s last fight would be to challenge for Pavlik’s Middleweight title, seeing as how brave sir Oscar of the Hoya has weighed in at 154 or so for his last 5 fights. Like you said, he had to strip naked to make 150 in May, so he is right there to fight at 160.

      THAT is an even fight. Looking for men 4 inches shorter and twenty pounds lighter to fight?

      For El Pollo type fighters.

      Or, could it be brave brave brave sir Oscar of the Hoya is afeared of Kelly?


    Have a Comment?

    Please use the box below to submit a comment. Before clicking the "submit" button, review the information above the button, or else your comment is subject to deletion.

    Before asking where a specific fighter is ranked or why they aren't ranked:

    - We update the rankings once per week, usually on Sunday or Monday.

    - Fighters who have not fought in 450 days or more ARE NOT RANKED UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES.

    - Use the "Fighter Search" option in the upper-right of the page. The fighter may be ranked in a different division.

    - Most of the divisions have multiple pages beyond this one. See the clickable ranges above and below the ranking table.


    Furthermore, we do not maintain the "next fight" data. This is gathered from Sherdog. Any issues regarding this data should be forwarded to them.